Ratings
5
out of 5
217
user ratings
Your rating
or to rate this recipe.
Have you cooked this?
or to mark this recipe as cooked.
Private Notes
Leave a Private Note on this recipe and see it here.
Cooking Notes
GF
Part 2 - The souring agent for sinigang varies from region to region in the Philippines. Sour fruits, such as kamias (Averrhoa bilimbi) and batuan (Garcinia morella) are commonly used, as are kalamansi (calamondin/citrofortunella), unripe guava and pineapple. Tomatoes are almost always added. Different cuts of pork and beef, meaty fish, shrimp and other crustaceans are the commonly used proteins singly, never combined. Sometimes water used to wash rice is used to add body to the soup.
GF
Part 1 - Make sure to use sour tamarind pulp and not the more commonly-available sweet and sour variety. Sinigang is meant to be sour-and-savory, not sweet-and-sour like other Southeast Asian soups (e.g., tom yum). There are sinigang powder mixes available but they are loaded with other ingredients such as monosodium glutamate.
Jean
Just say no to mushrooms, peppercorns and bayleaves, people! At the risk of sounding intolerant, this is one dish I feel strongly about. Do add those ingredients, but please don't call it sinigang.
Casey
yes, tamarind paste. Use caution - the paste might be more concentrated meaning cook has to dilute with water.since it's free of vegetable stuff - strings, fibers, seeds, tamarind pod shells, etc.) you could probably skip the bit about dissolving the tamarind pulp in a strainer.The strainer filters out the inedible, tough, chewy parts of the tamarind pulp.The paste is already cleaned for you.How much paste depends upon if it is concentrated or not, lie orange juice concentrate.
Lor
Growing up, I learned to make sinigang the way my grandma did. She'd use rice water (the cloudy water you get after washing rice - usually the second wash. The first is too dirty/dusty. ) It also helps the broth have a little more body for the sour tamarind, savory pork and umami rich fish sauce to grab onto. I've never heard of using powdered shiitake; I'm gonna need to try that and see what it adds to the flavor.
antonio
Do u have a recipe u prefer ? Lmk Thxs
Tracy Liang
THIS WAS A MUDDY MESS. We've rarely been steered wrong by NYT Cooking. We are experienced cooks with a broad range of skills, familiarity with Asian cuisines and a well-stocked pantry. We had tamarind pulp and dried shiitake mushrooms on hand. We enlisted all the requisite fresh ingredients including okra and came up with a sour, muddy barely palatable stew. Perhaps if you are from a Filipino family you have a good version of this dish. if not, this recipe will not endear you.
Natalie
Made exactly as is and loved it! Made again, forgot I didn’t have enough dried mushroom, subbed in ground perilla seed for a cup of lost shroom powder, and made a very good not-this-recipe soup. Glad I kept that stuff in my freezer
belier
shiitake mushrooms will surely add flavor but it isn't in traditional sinigang recipes. why not!
geri davis
We always use Gabi in our recipe & no eggplant or daikon.
Lor
Growing up, I learned to make sinigang the way my grandma did. She'd use rice water (the cloudy water you get after washing rice - usually the second wash. The first is too dirty/dusty. ) It also helps the broth have a little more body for the sour tamarind, savory pork and umami rich fish sauce to grab onto. I've never heard of using powdered shiitake; I'm gonna need to try that and see what it adds to the flavor.
Jean
Just say no to mushrooms, peppercorns and bayleaves, people! At the risk of sounding intolerant, this is one dish I feel strongly about. Do add those ingredients, but please don't call it sinigang.
antonio
Do u have a recipe u prefer ? Lmk Thxs
Micayla
Yes please, Jean, if you could share a recipe you prefer. Thank you.
wendy
What would be a substitute for tamarind pulp? tamarind paste?
leah
If you can't find tamarind, lemon juice can work in a pinch.
Casey
yes, tamarind paste. Use caution - the paste might be more concentrated meaning cook has to dilute with water.since it's free of vegetable stuff - strings, fibers, seeds, tamarind pod shells, etc.) you could probably skip the bit about dissolving the tamarind pulp in a strainer.The strainer filters out the inedible, tough, chewy parts of the tamarind pulp.The paste is already cleaned for you.How much paste depends upon if it is concentrated or not, lie orange juice concentrate.
KB
Lemon juice is not a good substitute. It won’t be sinigang without the tamarind.
GF
Part 2 - The souring agent for sinigang varies from region to region in the Philippines. Sour fruits, such as kamias (Averrhoa bilimbi) and batuan (Garcinia morella) are commonly used, as are kalamansi (calamondin/citrofortunella), unripe guava and pineapple. Tomatoes are almost always added. Different cuts of pork and beef, meaty fish, shrimp and other crustaceans are the commonly used proteins singly, never combined. Sometimes water used to wash rice is used to add body to the soup.
GF
Part 1 - Make sure to use sour tamarind pulp and not the more commonly-available sweet and sour variety. Sinigang is meant to be sour-and-savory, not sweet-and-sour like other Southeast Asian soups (e.g., tom yum). There are sinigang powder mixes available but they are loaded with other ingredients such as monosodium glutamate.
Private notes are only visible to you.